MENU

Hot Pepper Cheese Cubes
TO GET STARTED

6 Boneless Wings $8.99

Fries $4.25

Loaded Fries $8.75

Cheese Sticks $8.75

Fried Dough $6.50

Hot Pepper Cheese Cubes $8.75

Fried Zucchini $8.75

Onion Rings $8.75

Garlic Knots $7.50

Garlic Breadsticks $7.50

on our homemade bread, garlic butter, and melted mozzarella

Chicken Tenders $9.75

Small Fresh Chips $4.25

Pauly's Platter $14.99

chicken tenders, hot cheese cubes, cheese sticks, zucchini and onion rings

buffalo wings
IT'S A WING THING

Wing Sauces: Cajun, Lemon Pepper, Wet Ranch, Dry Ranch, Hot, BBQ, Garlic, Mild, hot - bbq, hot - garlic, strawberry hot, Parmesan garlic, honey bbq & Lousiana lickers.

WINGS 1/2 Dozen  $8.99

WINGS Dozen  $14.99

25 Wings  $27.99

Tuna salad
SALAD TIME & HOT SOUP

Homemade soup made daily ask your server for the selection.
Dressings: Italian, light Italian, French, blue cheese, ranch, sweet-and-sour, oil and Vinegar

Soup  Cup $3.75    Bowl $4.75   Quart $9.75

served with homemade bread

Large Tossed salad  $9.99

tomatoes, onions, green peppers, olives and cheese

Small Tossed salad  $7.99

Large Tuna salad  $12.99

tomatoes, onions, green peppers, olives and cheese

Small Tuna salad  $9.99

Chef salad  $12.99

ham, turkey, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, olives and cheese

Anti-Pasta Salad  $12.99

pepperoni, salami, hot and green peppers, tomatoes, onions, olives and cheese

Chicken Salad  $13.99

grilled or crispy chicken, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, olives, fries and cheese

Grilled Steak Salad $13.99

beautifully grilled steak, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, olives, fries and cheese

Lamb Salad  $14.99

cubed lamb, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, olives, fries and cheese

Breaded chicken sandwich
GOOD OLD HOT SANDWICHES

Hamburger $9.99

Cheeseburger $10.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich $9.99

Breaded Chicken Sandwich $9.99

Pepper & Egg Sandwich $8.99

Meatball & Cheese $11.99

Sausage & Cheese $11.99

Big Paul’s Big Fish Sandwich $11.99

Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie $11.99

Cheesesteak $11.99

grilled hot peppers, green peppers, mushrooms, onions & cheese

Smothered Chicken Sandwich $11.99

grilled hot peppers, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & cheese

Chicken & Greens Sandwich $11.99

grilled chicken, season greens and mozzarella cheese

Lamb Hoagie $13.99

Grilled hot peppers, onions, cheese, and garlic sauce on the side

Spicy Itailian Hoagie $12.99

Dirussos sausage sandwich $11.99

hot hoagie with chips
THE HOAGIE HOUSE

Bread made fresh daily. All hoagies served hot or cold with lettuce, onions, tomatoes, hot peppers, mayo or Italian dressing

Ham & Cheese Whole $10.99   Half $8.99

Turkey & Cheese Whole $10.99   Half $8.99

Pepperoni & Cheese Whole $10.99   Half $8.99

Salami & Cheese Whole $10.99   Half $8.99

Tuna & Cheese Whole $11.99   Half $9.99

Ham, Salami & Cheese Whole $11.99   Half $9.99

Turkey, Ham & Cheese Whole $11.99   Half $9.99

Pepperoni, Salami, & Cheese Whole $11.99   Half $9.99

Ham, Salami, Turkey & Cheese Whole $12.99   Half $10.99

Ham, Salami, Pepperoni & Cheese Whole $12.99   Half $10.99

House specialty pizzas
HOUSE SPECIALTY PIZZAS

Philly Steak Pizza

Philly Steak and Ranch Base
Personal $11.99 Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

Veggie Pizza

Cauliflower, Broccoli, Carrots, Ranch base
Personal $11.99 Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

Cheeseburger Pizza

Ground Beef, Lettuce, Tomato, Burger Sauce *Pickles optional
Personal $11.99 Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

White Pizza

Broccoli, tomato slices, onion, garlic, and olive oil
Personal $10.99  Medium $15.99  Large $18.99  Sicilian $20.99

Pierogi Pizza

Mashed potatoes, onions, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese
Personal $10.99  Medium $15.99  Large $18.99  Sicilian $20.99

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham and pineapple
Personal $10.99  Medium $15.99  Large $18.99  Sicilian $20.99

Sausage & Greens Pizza

Sausage and our famous seasoned greens & mozzarella
Personal $10.99  Medium $15.99  Large $18.99  Sicilian $20.99

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Crispy or grilled chicken dipped in our famous buffalo sauce
Personal $11.99  Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Pizza

Chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese & Ranch
Personal $11.99  Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

Supreme pizza

Choose any five toppings
Personal $11.99  Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

Pickle Pizza

Personal $11.99  Medium $16.99  Large $19.99  Sicilian $21.99

New York style pizza
NEW YORK STYLE PIZZAS

Toppings: Extra cheese, pepperoni, sausage, pineapple, mushrooms, green peppers, hot peppers, onions, black olives, anchovies, jalapenos, ham & bacon

New York Slice $2.25

(Extra toppings $.75 each)

Personal Pan Pizza $8.99

(Extra toppings $1.25 each)

Medium New York $11.99

(Extra toppings $1.75 each)

Large New York $13.99

(Extra toppings $2.00 each)

Square slice $3.00
(Extra toppings $.75 each)

Specialty slice $3.99

(Extra toppings $.75 each)

12 cut square $15.99

(Extra toppings $2.25 each)

pepperoni rolls
THE FAVORITES

Pepperoni Roll $8.99 (extra topping $.75)

Spinach Roll $8.99 (extra topping $.75)

Stromboli $9.99

includes two toppings, mozzarella cheese, and a side of sauce (extra topping $.75)

Calzone $10.99

includes two toppings, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese, and a side of sauce (extra topping $.75)

Penne pasta topped with marinara at Pizza Man's Pizza Restaurant New Castle, garnished with herbs.
DINNER TIME

All dinners do include a side salad and garlic bread

Spaghetti with Sauce $11.99

Gnocchi Dinner  $13.99

Spaghetti with Meatballs $13.99

Spaghetti with Sausage $13.99

Penne with Meatballs $13.99

Ravioli Dinner $13.99

Stuffed Shells $14.99

Chicken Parmesan $14.99

includes spaghetti, side salad, and garlic bread

Eggplant Parmesan $14.99

includes spaghetti, side salad, and garlic bread

A dark beverage poured over ice at Pizza Man's Pizza Restaurant New Castle on a black background.
DRINKS

Hot Tea and Coffee $2.99

All Fountain Drinks $3.25

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Lemon-Lime Soda, Root Beer, Cherry Pop, Pink Lemonade, Sweet & Unsweetened Tea

Pepperoni roll party tray
Party trays
PARTY TRAYS

Small Roll Tray $45.00

2 roni rolls, 2 spinach rolls

Large Roll Tray $60.00

3 roni rolls, 3 spinach rolls

Small Sicilian/Roll Tray $45.00

1 Sicilian, 1 roni roll, 1 spinach roll

Large Sicilian/Roll Tray $60.00

Large Sicilian, 2 roni rolls, 2 spinach rolls

Small Hoagie Tray (1-meat) $50.00

4 single-meat hoagies

Large Hoagie Tray (1-meat) $70.00

6 single meat hoagies

Small Hoagie Tray (2-meat) $55.00

4 two-meat hoagies

Large Hoagie Tray (2-meat) $75.00

6 two-meat hoagies

Small Hoagie Tray (3-meat) $60.00

4 three-meat hoagies

Large Hoagie Tray (3-meat) $80.00

6 three-meat hoagies

Disclaimer: Menu pricing and availability subject to change.